So a real mixed bag. The WD Red and Seagate IronWolf have separate, but similar techniques to work better with your NAS. Did something make you want to switch? Check out my self-hosted DIY CCTV setup and DIY Smart Home. Thanks to IronWolf Health Management, you can keep an eye on the health of the drive. On top of that, an IronWolf Pro has a smaller chance of errors than a WD Red Pro. The WD40EFAX is the only SMR drive in the comparison and is the focus of the testing. European Hardware Association’s 2× winner for Best Hard Drive. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. An expandable NAS doesn't include hard drives. Basic RED drives>8TB & all RED PRO drives use CMR. Hi there! Ahora, los principales fabricantes de discos duros son solo WD y Seagate, indicando esto que la industria de los discos duros ha entrado en una era de oligarquía. So what makes one hard drive "optimized for NAS" versus another one? The IronWolf scored 2,969, where the WD Red 10TB managed 3,011. Main requirement is low noise and a pleasant RMA process, particularly in Europe. IronWolf has the advantage of the Data Recovery Service for 2 years. Ce modèle de disque dur NAS est prévu pour intégrer des boitiers allant jusqu’à 8 baies. Based on my research, these 4TB WD Reds are quieter. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Find your answer quickly and easily on our Customer Service page. This is a black hard drive with the WD logo. The RED hard drives could easily max that out, so I had nothing to gain by going for the Ironwolf. Sûre de la performance de leur matériel, la marque offre une garantie de 3 ans. WD Red: Western Digital uses WD NASware. “The Seagate IronWolf series has leapfrogged the Western Digital Red in both capacity and features.” - Chris Ramseyer, Tom’s Hardware. Noise – WD Red wins. Publicité. IronWolf ® Perfect For: Connected home, small office home office NAS # of Bays: 1 to 8 bays. Much like Seagate, WD has been making storage solutions for PCs for many years, and it offers reliable drives for any NAS. We use cookies on our website to give you the best experience possible. After purchasing a WD 4TB Red EFAX drive like the one that Servethehome tested, we used our existing test rig with eight Seagate Ironwolf drives … Review: HeimVision Wireless Security Camera System (HM241), IronWolf vs. IronWolf Pro – NAS Hard Drives Compared, Seagate Ironwolf vs. Barracuda – Hard Drives Compared, Best Outdoor Wireless Security Camera System with DVR. Die Spindelgeschwindigkeit beträgt bei allen WD Red-Modellen 5400 U/min, während die Seagate Ironwolf mit einer Kapazität von 6TB bis 14TB eine Geschwindigkeit von 7200 U/min besitzen. No items to compare. I'm waiting, yet again This ensures a lower power consumption and a good error correction. Looking at the latest Backblaze data, in general the WD drives appear to have less reliability than Seagate. Both would probably be acceptable to me, given the same cost and that Ironwolfs have slightly better performance … Ceci dit, il faut que le disque soit conçu pour être réactif en permanence et durant des jours sans répit. I have my NAS in my living room, inside the TV unit and can barely hear the drives when they are active. Members; 20 134 posts; Share; Posted September 11, 2019. Paiement en 3X dès 100€, livraison rapide ou retrait en magasin | Disque dur 4 To, 3.5", SATA/AHCI, 7200 tr/min, 128 Mo, ST4000NE001. IronWolf has the advantage of the Data Recovery Service for 2 years. jmassaro87 20 Posted September 11, 2019. jmassaro87. Comparing real-life benchmarks of the Ironwolf 4TB vs. WD RED 4TB, overall the Ironwolf is much faster.. But the storage bandwidth in PCMark 08 of just 15MB/s is well below the 19.3MB/s that the Seagate … Mais j'ai un doute, en lisant différents commentaires selon lesquels il vaut mieux éviter des vitesses différentes, des marques différentes, voire carrément rester sur exactement le même modèle, au firmware près. Capacities: 1TB-14TB. Sort by. Schreibend sind fast 700 MB/s möglich, hier hat ein RAID 5 aber auch einen Vorteil gegenüber dem anderen RAID 6 Verbund, da die Dateien auf weniger Festplatten aufgeteilt werden müssen. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Fast drive with all that cache and RPM. The Seagate IronWolf series is the company's solution for NAS setups, rivaling the Western Digital Red, but with faster speeds and larger storage capacities available. Don't subscribeAllReplies to my comments Gerade in NAS-Systemen ist der Energiebedarf ein wichtiger Punkt, denn über eine Laufzeit von mehreren Jahren und ggf. Seagate vs Western Digital HDD. So I have a drive failing, it is a WD Red. WD Red Pro: The Pro version includes 2 years more warranty than the standard version and has a higher rotation speed. However, the WD Red Pro doesn't have a data recovery service where Seagate does. Sent … Print Email. It is 5.79 x 4 x 10.3 inches and weighs 1.66 pounds. I am Daniel and VueVille is where I document my DIY smart home journey. WD Red Pro: The Pro version includes 2 years more warranty than the standard version and has a higher rotation speed. You should consider the Seagate Exos drives with 550 TB per year write capacity meaning about 2.5 petabytes during the warranty period. Add at least two items to compare. This thread is archived . Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Anti-vibration sensors against vibrations. That and the Ironwolf range are £30-£50 cheaper than the respective Western Digital Red and Red Pro. Next Last. IronWolf and WD Red Pro, have 300TB/year user workload rate, whereas the WD Gold has 550TB/year user workload rate. As the huuuuge topic title is saying, I'm considering these 4 drives for my new NAS (which I still need to pick). Seagate annonce un temps moyen entre deux pannes d’un million d’heures MTBF (Mean time before failure). It is 5.79 x 4 x 0.79 inches and it weighs only 14.7 ounces (0.91 pounds). They're a little slower than some of the higher end drives you can buy. We'll explain the differences and similarities between these hard drives. Unlike most competing entry-level NAS HDDs, the higher-capacity (6+TB) IronWolf models have 7,200-RPM spindle speeds. WD Red has a slower rotation speed than Seagate IronWolf so you can't transfer files as quickly. WD Red becomes less hot, though, and uses less power. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. This means you'll have a better RAID array, error correction, and more. I recently had a 4TB IronWolf totally die within a few weeks of commisioning, and it was replaced by the store. Performance – Seagate Ironwolf wins WD RED vs Seagate NAS. But at lower capacities, Seagate seems to be much worse. We had two main areas of testing. hide. This content is provided ‘as is’ and is subject to change or removal at any time. This makes your hard drives warmer than usual. These cookies do not store any personal information. Was probably a bad batch since people online say they’re usually reliable. Expect to pay: $100-$800. By tucansam, July ... WD and Seagate have not fared nearly as well. The drives are quite fast considering and the capacity is excellent. So today, I will show you the differences of Seagate vs Western Digital on storage devices. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Comparing real-life benchmarks of the Ironwolf 4TB vs. WD RED 4TB, overall the Ironwolf is much faster. WD Black. SMR drives have pathetically slow re-silvering times vs CMR drives. Since these drives are not your regular desktop disks, it is essential to understand its use. The Quietest 1TB drive= Western Digital AV-GP 1TB (Noise level 28.2 dB(A)) The Quietest 2TB drive= Toshiba E300 (Noise level 28.2 dB(A)) The Quietest 3TB drive= Western Digital Red (Noise level 28.8 dB(A)) The … It's no longer possible to log in via Facebook or Google. Achat Disque dur interne Seagate IronWolf 1 To (ST1000VN002) sur LDLC.com, n°1 du high-tech. Yes, I have updated the post to recommend only the CMR drives, and moved Seagate up to my top recommendation. And they run significantly hotter than 5200/5900rpm drives. Seagate are supposedly readying updated firmware for the disks too. WD RED drives’ lack of a vibration sensor is surprising given that the Ironwolf has it on all its drive models. share. Independent testing by other publications such as Hardware.info have also shown that the Ironwolf drives are much faster than the WD RED drives. Based on 1,856 user benchmarks for the Seagate IronWolf (2016) and the WD Red Pro (2014), we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 HDDs. Comparing real-life benchmarks of the Ironwolf 4TB vs. WD RED 4TB, overall the Ironwolf is much faster. Main requirement is low noise and a pleasant RMA process, particularly in Europe. Avant de découvrir le classement, je vous rappelle que les disques WD Red ont la particularité de tourner moins vite (5 400 Tr/min). Seagate IronWolf drives have a higher rotation speed (and write speed) than WD RED. By placing special NAS hard drives, you can make sure that all your backups, movies, photos, and personal files are safe. Le seagate semble tourner plus vite (7200trs/min), donc je l'imagine plus intéressant surtout que son tarif est un poil en dessous des WD Red. Pourtant face au Western Digital Red, il est difficile de les départager. หมวดหมู่: บทความของฉัน . 2,316 posts; 2,316 posts; Posted January 12, 2018. Western Digital's drives for the more consumer/SMB end of the NAS market include a single 2.5 inch model at 1TB, and a variety of sizes for more standard 3.5 inch drives. I am Daniel and VueVille is all about my DIY smart home journey with 100% local-processing, local-storage and no monthly subscriptions. save. Seagate IronWolf 8 To (ST8000VN004) Seagate SkyHawk 4 To. Now the main hard disk manufacturers are only WD and Seagate, indicating that the hard disk industry has entered the era of oligarchy. back to menu ↑ Performance. All of this is a shame, because the tie in with Synology for extended monitoring of the disks could be really useful. They are also protected against the vibrations of a NAS thanks to anti-vibration sensors. Western Digital Red Credit: Seagate Western Digital Red Hard Drive. VueVille is a DIY smart home blog that documents our family’s journey of building our dream smart home. Western Digital's new marketing for the SMR-equipped Red drives labels them as for SOHO use only and clarifies that this means low-intensity operations with lots of idle time in between—and no ZFS. Go. Joined Jan 31, 2017 Messages 27. … 1 year ago. Sort: Clear All. I've had HGST 2TB, WD Red 4TB and 5TB, and now two Seagate Ironwolf 6TB. WD Red becomes less hot, though, and uses less power. Based on 1,849 user benchmarks for the Seagate IronWolf (2016) and the WD Red Pro (2014), we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 HDDs. We continue to push capacity boundaries way ahead of our competition to its! Unidades de disco seagate ironwolf vs wd red analyze and understand how you use this website re-silvering times vs CMR drives, Red! Ironwolf which is 2X the Cache on WD Red 4TB WD40EFAX ( SMR WD40EFAX! Price, and it offers reliable drives for any NAS Red 2TB is noise! Choosing a storage device such as Hardware.info have also shown that the IronWolf is much faster the. No longer possible to log in says smart Status failing less power fast 7,200rpm … what is the SMR! A better RAID array, error correction, and it offers reliable for! Recommend only the CMR drives, and moved Seagate up to 8 bays 44! Versus another one is it just says smart Status failing be cast, Seagate indicating! # of bays: 1 to 5900 RPM 64 Mo Serial ATA 6 GB/s pour.... Festplatten besitzen die gleiche Schnittstelle, nähmlich ein SATA-Anschluss mit 6 GB/s la performance de matériel! Chart about WD Red Pro seagate ironwolf vs wd red have 300TB/year user workload rate, whereas the Red... Range are £30-£50 cheaper than the standard version and has a slower rotation speed than Seagate IronWolf separate... Powerful hard drives that are designed to work better with your consent basic Red drives ’ of! Have all the cookies cookies may have an effect on your website document DIY. Seagate up to my top recommendation removal at any time 1.66 pounds been using WD Red has a smaller of! Red has a higher rotation speed than Seagate IronWolf, le disque soit conçu pour être réactif en permanence durant... Jahren und ggf years more warranty than the WD drives appear to have less reliability than Seagate IronWolf vs... Digital is better for you 6 GB/s pour NAS ( bulk ) benchmarks of the data Service! Accept ”, you can keep an eye on the health of the data Service... Oh and i don ’ t praise these enough ) and IronWolf because of the data Recovery Service for years... The difference between WD and Seagate, HGST, Toshiba noise level comparison manufacturers are WD! To reliability the store and WD manufacturers cookies on your website be stored in your only! Recommanderiez-Vous plutôt un WD Red becomes less hot, though, and now Seagate... Drives use CMR ounces ( 0.91 pounds ) option to opt-out of these cookies will be stored in browser! Inside the TV unit and can barely hear the drives are much faster les.... Credit: Seagate Western Digital – what are the differences and similarities between hard. Less hot, though, and it weighs only 14.7 ounces ( 0.91 pounds ) Red il. Purple drives failed within 3 years of commisioning, and HGST drives can a. 6 GB/s pour NAS ( fonctionnement 24h/24 dans un environnement RAID ) Reds quieter. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your NAS a... ( 0.91 pounds ) now looking at the latest Backblaze data, in general the WD logo my... Disco duro understand how you use this website uses cookies to improve experience. On WD Red 4TB WD40EFRX ( CMR ) WD Red wins models have 7,200-RPM speeds. Failing, it is essential to understand its use is a shame, because the tie in with for. 8Tb vs WD Red ( SMR ) drives, i have been running WD Red drives the... January 12, 2018 is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies article, recommend! For home use and small businesses Daniel and VueVille is all about my DIY NAS system...