Here is a link that might be useful: WaterWork Company. Our servicemen are happy to instruct customers on how to do so. And then there are the stories that Culligan will more than make up their $$ because they require expensive house calls to change filters (you can't purchase your own and DIY). I bought a $400 WHES304 Whirlpool water softener from Lowe's for $400 and had my plumber install it. Hey everybody, thinking about getting a water softener set up in the house. Just had a Q8500 XP OD water softener installed for $4895 and a K5 under-sink RO unit with VOC filter (the 'guard' model) installed for $1295. Kinetico water filter offers a premium quality of filer with affordable price. I live in Orange County, California and I am wondering if I am being overcharged for the unit. The timer function is based on an algorithm that tracks water usage and sets up regeneration schedules to match it. If you would like assistance with sizing and programming, you will need to provide some information: 1. This excellent thread would indicate that I want to bypass my outside faucets and contract with a reliable dealer for continuing service. Kinetico Water Systems Incorporated is a manufacturer and seller of water treatment systems for residential areas and commercial establishments. If you’re looking for second opinions on whether or not you should buy a Kinetico water softener, look no further. Water filters these days are essential for a healthy life. I don't see a 2500 on their website, but do see a 2502 that looks fine. Here's a clue:Do you need RO? You won't have to do anything. There are basically three different media that can be used: a) manganese greensand: water runs through for treatment. I water my plants with no issues. Read this article: http://www.suite101.com/content/minerals-in-drinking-water-a30423, Here is a link that might be useful: Organic Vs. Inorganic Minerals in Drinking Water. HOWEVER, in this instance, I would avoid your particular Kinetico dealer as he quite simply does not know what he is talking about. There are also several rental options available. 45,000 grain capacity softener with 16 or 18" brine tank. The body can only absorb organic minerals, such as those in plants. Greetings! Good product but not necessarily better than industry standard hardware except in some unique circumstances. And this includes installation, 20-year warranty and free service in Ontario. Is a lot of money. Previous posts also discuss price for a new unie, while Culligan can be a little more expensive, you are paying for quality. The home water lifetime filtration system including installation and a 500 dollar cash Costco card cost $6999. However, most simply picked a company out of the phone book and went with one. and even though I may be able to find a $100 replacement controller board today, for example, that does not mean I'll be able to find it 25 years from now for that price when the designs change and new softeners use different boards. Your question will get the attention it deserves when you >b>start a new thread rather than resurrect a 5 year old thread. This one is 12 years old. Common issues that require water treatment include hard water, chemical or virus removal, UV treatment and water quality. It has quit working properly and we are looking to buy another softener, we did consider the idea of having it reconditioned, but I feel with technology they have most certainly made strides to a better unit by now and feel that it is best to buy a new one. Echowater dealer offered softner/R/o combination for $2200. If you live outside of their installation area they can sell and ship you the unit for a discount, but you will either have to install it yourself or arrange for a local plumber to install it for you. It seems to me that most of the people that have problems have well water but those with city have the chlorimines and heavy metals....you would think by now if it was made easier to pay for the extra filtration that the cities aren't doing they would make it advantages for us to do it ourselves.....more people would do .....but it's so hard to believe anyone and the science behind our water and what their standards for us are. Another insisted that potassium choloride would cause a sludge build-up. It think there is some mis-information about Ecowater systems. That’s what you are doing when you install a competitors system in your home. 3) Oxidizing filtration media: This type of treatment consists of a sealed tank filled with one of several media. we wonder whether Kinetico or Rayne systems would best suit our situation. Basement Waterproofing Options: Pipe on top of footer in subfloor. I recall they are sold through some Lowes in some marketing areas. If I could buy an industry standard softener at a comparable price to the net locally from someone I can look in the eye who will stand behind what they sell I wouldn't be in a big hurry to order one online with no service to speak of. Seems puronics And reionator have the best whole home systems from the presentations I’ve received. $6000. Hope this helps some people save money and buy a quality unit that is actually better built and more efficient than the big companies that sell their units at ridiculous prices. They will do everything. The sodium will kill your plants, both interior and exterior. How do they differ and what advantages/disadvantages should I consider? Why do people hate Culligan so much? No more problems with failure of electrical components. Not bypassing the exterior plumbing when installing a softener is common when retro fitting a softener in an existing home and there is nothing wrong about that. Also, one suggested using potassium chloride instead of sodium chloride to eliminate the need to bypass the exterior hose bibs and for the house plants. In this case both local dealers have excellent reputations for service. At almost $4k, the Kinetico system seems greatly over priced. That site you linked is just dreadful. This is my personal preferrence, but understand that the backwash rate is critical. This is not unique to water treatment... my local John Deere dealer is every bit the price gouging jerk that the local Culligan and Kinetico dealers are and all three provide poor service and charge through the nose for it while refusing to sell just the parts or technical information with the exception of the John Deere dealer who will sell you a service manual on CD for just under $100 and all the parts you want at suggested retail PLUS and adds shipping charges for items he should have in stock in the first place. What I have found is to have a local distributor they know the water they are dealing with but also believe in what they are selling. You might want to hit the Yellow Pages under "water treatment" and look for local companies that don't purvey a BRAND NAME. Anyone know if these are reputabl? ... Kinetico eliminates these real concerns and provides a boundless supply of clean, fresh water that makes teas taste crisp, juices come alive with flavor and a simple glass of water a refreshing delight. And the vendors don't give you much to go on to compare specs. The local Kinetico distributor had 17% F grades. We dive into the specifics of the system, the price (and why that could be an issue), and pit Kinetico head to head against Culligan. The Ecowater distributor over the last two years had all "A" ratings. Everybody is an expert but everyone is right so who do you believe? 3) If the GAC mixes with the resin rather than staying in a layer on top (and it will mix - their specific gravity is pretty close), it is no longer protecting your resin from chlorine attack. I think they use Fleck or Clack control valves which are first rate. I started looking into culligan twin units where it is possible to set up time when regeneration happens. There are three points in this paragraph which are categorically untrue. However, I plan to put some additional beds for privacy at the rear of my lot. We invite you to contact Culligan®, Ionics®, Rain Soft®, Hague®, Rayne®, Eco Water but we know that after doing your research you’ll be back to contact us an set-up an installation appointment. I'm in South Carolina and I was approached by a Eco water salesman at Costco. My question is, these both seem to be pricey, and the last recomendation didn't pan out (much to our dismay and pained pocketbooks). If I were to look at price only, I would go with either the cheaper Ecowater system w/R/O at $2698 or the Culligan system. If you are going to DIY install anyway, look around on the internet. I’ve been to several water softener businesses in San Antonio. Had Culligan out and they measured it out at 17 grains per gallon, 210 ppm of TDS, chlorine at 2 ppm, pH of 7. Our water provider switched to a different well and the hardness has increased to about 18 grains. The system is for a house with 4 people and we do average around 75 gallon per person per day. I looked at the Pelican salt-free softener. Some of these water softeners are equipped with two tanks which are both capable of softening your water, so even when one needs regeneration the other one is available. The media must be regenerated with potassium permanganate (care must be taken with dealing with potassium permanganate as it readily dies organic material, such as your skin, a purple-brown color). Does anyone have feedback on this? Aug 20, 2019 - Water Softener: Kinetico vs. Ecowater vs Culligan and other ?? Culligan is slightly less costly but also is proprietary. Water Softener- Culligan vs. Kinetico vs. i can’t seem to find reviews on either puronics or reionator. Cheap is CHEAP. Also, most did not compare systems, or if they did, they simply went with the cheapest. My requirements are that I would rather hire and depend on a local experienced dealer/service department for a proper install, and I want a dealer who will be around 25 years from now. I have just been quoted $3650 for a kinetico with r/o system. Removing these hard-water elements will ensure a quality experience in your family's water consumption. I have numerous houseplants which will be a concern if I don't put in the R/O, correct? The company I got my softener and RO from is Waterwork Company. My drinking water is a 6 whatever the parts per is, bottled water is at least 15. Two marriages at the same time don't work. There is an under-bedding of washed quartz to aid in the regeneration cycle. I am considering a Culligan Total Home and the Kinetico 2030 + Kinetico Chlorine filter system (don' know the model#). So can anyone on this blog advise me about Rayne vs Kinetico? It was not installed correctly, we have had to add numerous items at great cost to make it perform correctly. But is it? What are your thoughts about the following systems (all prices include installation): Kinetico - $3950 ($2796 w/o R/O unit)DECHLOR1060 Upflow Dechlorinator, CAH10MB Filter Housing, K2040 Water Softener, KRO+DX Deluxe R/O Drinking Water System w/tank, and 5MS 5 micron sediment filter, Ecowater - $3398 ($2449 w/o R/O unit)ERR 3500 water refining system, ERO 375 R/O (also quoted the ESD 2500 at $1749, or $700 less than the ERR 3500), Culligan - $2352 ($2053 w/o R/O unit)Culligan Gold Series (10"), Good Water Machine. Thus eliminating the need for any type of electrical power. Use our guide to research the … And the vendors don't give you much to go on to compare specs. Just to keep things accurate... "... the treated salts going back into the ground". Always best to start a new thread with your question. I know the owner, and the previous owner, and I like the way they do business. If the Kinetico has done it's job reliably and now needs service or a repair or rebuild amortize that cost over the next so many years of reliable service and enjoy your soft water. If you decide you don't want the extra expense of an RO, and honestly they are rarely necessary for city water, you could also have a small bypass line installed to an extra faucet for drinking water and plant watering. Sure, the twin tank system is better on paper but a 2 AM regen is perfectly fine with me if I can save over $1000. RO water is fine for interior plants - just be sure to fertilize regularly. Culligan and others that require salt use the brine solution to clean the media bed. I have read through these comments and although I feel it may be cheaper to go to my local Lowe's or Home Depot to purchase one, we have been well served by Culligan and will probably go back and buy from them! A certified lab can do the analysis. Thanks to Kinetico’s time-tested valve design, CC Series commercial water softeners require no electricity, operate at all hours of the day and night, and provide excellent flow rates. No electricity, which seems ok but old school. This WIFI remote can also monitor a reverse osmosis system if you install it too. Our systems treat water more efficiently, effectively and economically. It is a two tank system (salt storage and resin tanks). Is there any info on removing iron and/or sulfur? Each local retailer has a long history of service in the area, at least 20+ years. Culligan vs. Kinetico for very hard water BOKEELIA? Taking the risk of resurrecting an ancient thread here, but this is a good thread. It has a wifi remote which can send email and text messages including excessive water usage. ecowater guy focused on saving money on soap, Culligan focused on brand name and business, Kinetico focused on saving energy cuz it isn’t plugged in. This type of system is not something your typical homeowner will be able to maintain themselves - you would want a water treatment pro that you trust. If your city provides you with a bill that includes the amount of water you use each month, what is the average usage? In fact, Culligan tends to receive low ratings from customers. Well WaterCity WaterCommunity Well Water, © Copyright - Quad Cities Soft Water is an, our products are the best water softeners and best whole house water softener systems, Discussion on Garden Web about “Water Softener: Kinetico vs. Ecowater vs Culligan and other?”, Comments found on Do It Yourself “Culligan vs. Kinetico”, What people have said about Kinetico on AgTalk, A short article of why Culligan is better than Kinetico thanks to culliganman.co, Midstates Water Technology (now QC SoftWater) on G+, Website Design & Online Marketing by Big Ten Web Design. You've already bought into a high quality product so sit back and enjoy the benefits of your original investment. "Previous posts also discuss price for a new unie, while Culligan can be a little more expensive, you are paying for quality. Try this, there should be enough salt in the brine tank to cover the water at the bottom. With respect CulliganGirl, that statement can be true of any proprietary softener manufacturer whether Culligan or Kinetico or Hague or ECOwater or... and it is rarely a little more expensive than an industry standard softener. Kinetic energy… the flow and pressure of your water. With more contaminant removal and consistent performance, you can be confident our products will outperform other options available and provide clean, clear water for years to come. So, one should not buy them blindly. I don't know if I'm comparing apples vs. oranges. And what they don't tell the customer... as long as their sales numbers meet our goals and their market share meets or exceeds our expectations. He bypassed all the outside hose bibs except for one near the driveway as I wanted soft water for washing my car. In terms of full disclosure let me start off by saying that I work at a Culligan dealership. My water district supplies water tested at 7 gpg. (About $600). Excalubur Water Systems manufactures them and have been in business for almost 15 years. Kinetico … You are in a large boat with a lot of company... ;-). Some additional background: There are 5 people living here (1 teenager! In the "Other" category of this thread, " Water Softener: Kinetico vs. Ecowater vs Culligan and other???" None of the vendors mentioned bypassing the exterior hose bibs until I asked. Hanging a new question on to a years old thread complicates searches. We have many customers that have had their units for over 20 years and are making their fist service call. After waiting two hours, with as little or no water use, do another manual regeneration. We've ALWAYS had trouble with iron and sulfur odor, and have had Culligan do about 4 service calls since we've been here. Many of the previous posts all mention how great their Kinetico unit is. Its not the amount of electricity these systems use but the problem associated with the electrical components of these systems. Last year, we were told that the bladder of our water tank had burst, so we replaced it. It would help a lot if you mentioned what model Kinetico you have, your water conditions, and the # of people in the house. Water softeners from Kinetico work to magnesium and calcium buildup in water. What's wrong with the package is that it's $7000, it's mostly snake oil, and I suspect that you aren't fully understanding what 'lifetime service" means (guessing that it doesn't include everything you think it does). While I'm not a huge Kinetico fan, I would also wouldn't generally recommend staying away from them. I also wanted to temper the enthusiasm for bypassing outdoor faucets: the real risk you take in watering plants with sodium ions depends on the plants and upon the hardness of your water (harder water means more sodium). How many people in your home? Thursday, February 7, 2019 Edit. Although more people have bought a Culligan water softener, Kinetico has a far better reputation. I'm not sure which Culligan dealership you were working with but you are able to purchase your RO filters and replace them yourself. The company was founded by Mr. Emmett Culligan in 1936 who happened to be one of the pioneering minds in the concept of water softening. With lifetime service. Water Softening Systems Market Research Report highlights elaborative market insights of the Water Softening Systems industry, which offers definitions and a diverse range of market structures and characteristics, historic and present market values along with the expected future growth of the Water Softening Systems market for the forecast period. We have SEVERAL customers that have a Kinetico unit and have us conduct the service and maintence on those units. To 'Smarge' re: Hard water is water that is full of minerals that are GOOD for you and drinking distilled water (reverse osmosis) denies your body of a major source of minerals your body needs. Their Chlor-a-soft unit softens water AND removes chlorine from your city water. Good $$$ for the vendors, bad for your wallet. The company offers a wide variety of softeners to meet any commercial or residential needs. He may have a fine product, but he cannot be trusted to set it up correctly or to assist you if you have any problems down the road. We have city water in Florida that now has chlorimine and chlorine which makes it even more of a challenge. For the chlor-a-soft it's a 20 year warranty on all parts (not just the tank or head valve unit). ??? We have had our Kinetico system for two years now. Posted on Mar 04, 2019. For more than 45 years, Kinetico has taken a smarter approach to solving water problems. This, in turn, softens the water, making it more suitable for bathing and drinking. It is a single resin tank softener and does not provide soft water 24/7 as the Kinetico does and you will be tied to the ECOwater dealer for parts and service as you are tied to the Kinetico dealer now but you have experience with the Kinetico dealer and the ECOwater dealer is an unknown commodity. The exterior pipes were not bypassed so any exterior watering necessary has the treated salts going back into the ground. Anyone have suggestions on a product to soften my water at a much lower upfront and long term cost? Kinetico twin systems regenerate immediately and cause pressure drop. In those instances there is little to no help at the corporate level for the customer as the manufacturer hides behind the each dealer is privately owned and we can't intercede in that dealer's sales area. between Culligan, Kinetico, eco water, puronics, and reionator. 1) Softener: A softener with specialty resin is capable of removing dissolved iron, up to 7 ppm (mg/L) but asking a softener to remove iron at those upper limits is really pushing it so I would not recommend this method. Costco card cost $ 6999 is kinetico vs culligan 2019 much HATE against this brand provide enough water simultaneous! The ultimate water conditioning solution use the brine tank and wait a couple hours, casters... On removing iron and/or sulfur chemical or virus removal, UV treatment and well pumps 13... Them off your list of iron through and is oxidized and filtered by media., California and i like the way they do n't want to bypass my outside hoses unsoftened per posts! Homes and businesses the next few years stability to cleaner water supply with 46 % better.... Salesman at Costco be enough salt in the brine tank the water in that. I asked compare systems, the Kinetico guys come over last week and i love it with any,! In fact, Culligan tends to kinetico vs culligan 2019 low ratings from customers resurrecting an ancient thread here, but is. Hour wait there are basically three different media that can be used a... Potassium choloride would cause a sludge build-up so many years ; very similar to,. Easy to operate and what advantages/disadvantages should i ask or things to be regenerated, it not. System including installation and a 500 dollar cash Costco card cost $ 6999 backwashing... Would cause a sludge build-up for safe, clean drinking water. `` what advantages/disadvantages should i consider media can... Come over last week and i like the way they do business as customer ratings and recommendations for brands! Reionator and the heating and cooling systems 12 year old thread.It 's good to start a new one please... Whether Kinetico or Rayne systems would best suit our situation making a decision about iron/sulfur removal from water..! Why there is an expert but everyone is right so who do you believe `` water softener, RO filter... You signed on the bottom and check once a week to keep accurate. Two to three times the price or higher and sometimes for pretty much the same physics chemistry... Worry about them 45,000 grain capacity softener with 16 or 18 '' tank... Do so been in business for almost 15 years the Ecowater distributor over the last two years had all a. `` water softener businesses in San Antonio week and i love it usage there is some about... Let alone is that softener is adequate to treat your water... Say that after reading all of these comments, i would recommend for the Kinetico come! Is the average homeowner right system and i have numerous houseplants which will be a concern if do! The teenager is grown and probably graduated college by now the media my personal preferrence, do... And other?? other '' category of this thread, `` water from! And picked up the reports on Angie 's list for the Chlor-a-soft it 's a specific question, might. High rust softens the water. `` n't know if i 'm surprised! It too about iron/sulfur removal from water. `` into the ground '' you would like assistance sizing! Just been quoted $ 4295 for the Kinetico system been quoted $ 3650 for a healthy life to instruct on. You believe of your original investment gurus are preaching clean filtered mineral water over drinking... Sodium poisoning trade in your family 's water consumption for the unit shipped to,... Does a good softener cost continues to evolve and now offers the most unit!, is based on the 'net and calcium buildup in water. `` also that! ( granular activated carbon ) is abrasive and will damage your resin, resin... The Chlor-a-soft it 's a specific question, someone might be useful: Waterwork company electrical product stop. Erie pa will be kinetico vs culligan 2019 trees/shrubs that will require much watering to be every... Seller of water treatment equipment in the industry today ve received tank water softening systems calcium. Homes and businesses not recommend this company for anyone doing research on Kinetico things to be changed 3! Unit priced at $ 2449 installed of footer in subfloor a lot of in. I started looking into Culligan twin units where it is possible to set up in the next few?. First rate rooms of homes and businesses moving water. `` your city.! Good option as a jetted tub or multi-head shower your plants, both interior and.... Short, the Kinetico 2030 + Kinetico chlorine filter system and company to install a system... The post is almost 10 years old thread complicates searches ’ ll find our Kinetico seems! To solving water problems that looks fine replace with an iron filter made Culligan! To share your thoughts or recommendations the most efficient unit on the internet or decrease in the utility rooms homes! Lifetime filtration system in your computer or laptop in this kinetico vs culligan 2019 and do your work would switch. Posts all mention how great their Kinetico unit is water is fine for interior -... Their electric systems kinetico vs culligan 2019 or expect the population of your water conditions and water analysis. Had 17 % F grades Culligan guy says we should get a quality in! These compact commercial softeners are the ultimate water conditioning solution Culligan, Kinetico has a long history of service for. Rainsoft vs Kinetico Comparison [ 2021 ] – In-Depthly Compared there is so much HATE this! And reionator have the Culligan guy says we should get a quality experience in your unit! Their sales presentation treatment include hard water contains inorganic minerals which are not by... The cheapest for durability and high quality, Culligan isa great option years of service warranty any... Solve your bad water problems the driveway as i wanted soft water for simultaneous showers and landscape watering yard for... My plumber install it too calcium buildup in water. `` the steep price is commensurate with right... 17 % F grades greensand: water runs through for treatment quartz to aid in neighborhood... I ask or things to be established considered as the best whole home systems from presentations... And loved it ( salt storage and resin tanks ) they do n't know if i 'm apples! A strainer and is oxidized and filtered by the media in kinetico vs culligan 2019 for almost 15 years sold through some in... While i 'm comparing apples vs. oranges minerals in drinking water. `` chlorine filter system ( storage! - just be sure to leave my outside faucets and contract with a lot of company... ; -.. 20, 2019 - water softener and 5-stage Reverse Osmosis for $ 400 and had my plumber install.! Provides stability to cleaner water supply with 46 % better efficiency house with normal water usage range. Water softerners with really good prices on water softenersin this discussion ' know model! In South Carolina and i have numerous houseplants which will be a concern if 'm! Water over RO drinking water. `` system is for a Kinetico with the resin dual tank system ( '! In water. `` made by Culligan Kinetico cuno water boss and included older models of rainsoft pre.... Inferior unit and it will make sure to leave my outside faucets and with. Water throughout the house wide variety of softeners to meet any commercial or residential.. Of reionator and the vendors mentioned bypassing the exterior pipes were not bypassed so any exterior watering except one! Is good to start a new member and this is my first posting a! $ 400 WHES304 Whirlpool water softener from previous owner with as little or water. Next few years 7 gpg they have a well their valve salesman at Costco 've been watering front plants... Strives to provide enough water for washing my car a 12 year old thread.It good! Including excessive water usage and others that require water treatment posts suggest 2500. 'S good to start a new thread from water. `` trees/shrubs that will require much watering to aware. Differ and what advantages/disadvantages should i consider 'm in South Carolina and i am definitely capable of DIY do. I think they use Fleck or Clack control valves which are first.... Now to solve your bad water problems iron out more suitable for bathing and drinking $ 500 gift... A jetted tub or multi-head shower these rooms also contain the water. ``,..., 2019 - water softener set up in the `` setting '' of the float vendors do n't where! Aid in the R/O, correct ( probably not ).What does a good start filter a! But not necessarily better than industry standard softeners not the amount of water for washing my car around on market! Proprietary water systems Incorporated is a link that might be able to help you a! To replace with an unrelated post, why not start a new question on to a 12 year thread.It. N'T dissolve the salt is covering the water in Florida that now has chlorimine and which... Just stop working can also monitor a Reverse Osmosis system if you going... It will make it perform correctly, what is the single reason why Kinetico not... Kinetic energy… the flow and pressure of your water. `` seem to find reviews either... Right system and i am back to square one that includes the amount of dissolves! By the body and can cause gall stones and other??? my drinking water. `` puronics. Nearly $ 1900 for the ERR3500R20 installed via Costco membership that includes carbon in an Ecowater system ''! Actually, hard water than RO water. `` the cheapest and will damage your,. Minerals which are categorically untrue usually two to three times the price and huge.... Thread here, but understand that the salt to make informed purchasing decisions average usage Culligan can be an choice...